Advice

OpenView or DStv: the trade-off, set out plainly

This decision comes down to two things: how you want to pay, and what you are willing to give up in exchange. Everything else is detail, and most of the detail changes too often to be worth basing a decision on.

Two satellite decoders side by side on a lounge cabinet beneath a wall-mounted television

We install and repair both, which means we have nothing to gain from steering you either way. That is the only reason this page is worth reading rather than the ones written by people who do.

Before anything else, a note on what this page deliberately does not contain. There are no prices, no package names and no channel numbers here. Those change, sometimes several times a year, and a page that fixes them in print is a page that misleads somebody in eighteen months. What does not change is the shape of the decision, and that is what follows.

The question is a cost model, not a channel count

OpenView is a once-off equipment cost with no monthly subscription fee. You buy the decoder, you pay for the installation, and after that the service costs nothing each month. The only running cost is the electricity the box uses.

DStv is a subscription. You pay every month for as long as you want a picture, and in exchange you get a far larger line-up, including the live sport that customers most often name to us as the reason they stay.

That is the whole trade-off, and it is worth sitting with for a moment before looking at anything else. One is cheap to run and narrow. The other is broad and never stops costing. Neither of those is a fault. They are two different products aimed at two different households, and the mistake people make is treating OpenView as a cheaper version of DStv rather than as a different thing.

Side by side, on the parts that actually differ

What you are weighing upOpenViewDStv
How you payOnce, for the equipment and installation. No monthly subscription fee.Every month, for as long as you want it.
Breadth of the line-upOpenView's own claim is over 20 TV and radio channels, including SABC channels and e.tv.Considerably broader. Check the current line-up on DStv's own site rather than going on memory.
Live sportDo not assume a competition is there. Check the current line-up before you commit to anything.The reason most of the households we speak to keep paying.
The decoderThe OV512, which OpenView describes as Wi-Fi capable.DStv's own decoders.
Starting at an address that already has a dishOften a small job. OpenView connects to an existing dish pointing north-east.Also often a small job, for the same reason. The dish does not care which service is behind it.
Going away for three monthsNothing happens. There is nothing to pause and nothing to restart.A subscription matter to arrange with DStv, not a technical one.
When a picture disappearsAlways physical: dish, LNB, cable, connector or decoder.Physical, or an account state. The error code on the screen tells you which.

That last row is more useful than it looks. On a subscription service, roughly half the no-picture calls we take are not technical at all, and the code on the screen says so. Our article on what to check before you phone anyone covers how to sort those two categories in about ten minutes.

Sport is where the honest answer usually lands

If we are going to be useful rather than diplomatic: sport is what decides this for most households, and it decides it in DStv's favour more often than not.

We are not going to tell you which competition appears where. Sports rights move between broadcasters, sometimes with very little notice, and any page that lists them is wrong eventually. What we will say is that if a specific competition is the reason your television is on at all, that fact should be checked directly on the providers' own sites before you cancel anything, and checked again rather than remembered from last season.

Households where the sport is occasional rather than structural usually find the answer easier. Households where somebody watches every fixture of something tend not to switch, and there is nothing wrong with that conclusion.

What your house already has changes the sums

The once-off cost of going to OpenView is not a fixed figure, because it depends on what is already on your wall. A house that has just cancelled a subscription usually has a dish pointing north-east, a bracket fixed into something solid, an LNB, and a cable already run through the wall. In that situation the switch is a decoder and a short visit.

A house with nothing outside is a full installation and a different sum entirely. And a house with a dish that has stood unused for three years sits in between: the bracket may be perfect, the aim may have drifted, and the connectors have had three winters of Cape Town weather. What that assessment involves is set out on our OpenView dish page.

This is the single most practical piece of advice on this page: do not take an old dish down before somebody has looked at it. Removing it turns a short job into a long one and throws away the part that is hardest to replace, which is a mounting that is properly fixed into a wall.

The households that end up with both

It is worth saying that this is not always an either-or. A good number of homes we work in keep the subscription on the main television and put OpenView on the second set, in the cottage or in the room that gets a couple of hours of viewing a week. Because there is no monthly fee on the OpenView side, that second box adds nothing to what the household pays each month once it is in.

Whether both can run off one dish is a question about the LNB on the arm and the cabling that already exists, and it is settled by looking at what is up there rather than in principle. Sometimes it is a straightforward extra run. Sometimes the honest answer is that a second feed means a second cable, which we would rather say when quoting than halfway through an afternoon. The same logic applies to a second DStv decoder, which is what XtraView is for.

How to settle it in one evening

  1. Write down what your household actually watches

    Not what you would like to watch. The five or six things that are genuinely on. Most people are surprised by how short the list is once it is written down.

  2. Check each of those against the current line-ups

    On the providers' own sites, not on a comparison page and not on this one. This is the only step that matters and it takes about ten minutes.

  3. Work out what is already on your wall

    A dish, a bracket, a cable through the wall, a wall plate behind the television. Every one of those that survives is work nobody has to pay for, whichever way you go.

  4. Compare a once-off number against twelve months of subscription

    Then against twenty-four. That comparison is where the cost model becomes concrete, and it is the calculation most people have not actually done.

  5. Decide what you would do if you got it wrong

    Going back is not difficult in either direction, and the dish on the wall serves both. Knowing that removes most of the anxiety from the decision.

For the mechanics of the free-to-air side, our article on how OpenView works goes through the parts and where the money goes. For the subscription side, DStv installation covers what a working installation needs. Both are the same four parts outdoors.

Questions we get asked

I only want to cut the bill. Is OpenView automatically the answer?
Only if what you watch is on it. The saving is real and it is permanent, but it is bought with a narrower line-up, so the honest test is to write down what your household actually watches and check each item against the current OpenView list. If everything on that list is there, the decision makes itself.
Will I still be able to watch live sport if I switch?
Some, but not on the assumption that a particular competition will be there. Broadcast rights move between providers and we are not prepared to publish a claim about them that will be wrong next season. Check the specific competition you care about on the providers' own sites before you cancel anything.
Can I try OpenView without cancelling DStv first?
Yes, and it is a sensible way to do it. Run OpenView on a second television for a month while the subscription is still live, and you will find out what your household misses rather than guessing. Whether both can feed off the existing dish depends on the LNB and cabling already up there.
Does switching mean a whole new installation?
Usually not. The dish, the bracket and the cable are the expensive parts of an installation and they are shared between the two services, so a house that has just cancelled a subscription often needs only a decoder and a check of what is outside. That changes if the dish has stood unused for years, because the aim and the connectors will both need attention.
If I switch and regret it, how hard is it to go back?
Not very. The outdoor half of the installation serves both services, so going back is largely a matter of the decoder and the account rather than the roof. Keep the old decoder in a cupboard for a couple of months rather than disposing of it immediately, because people do change their minds.
Which one handles bad weather better?
Neither, and any claim otherwise is a sales line. Both are satellite services using the same physics, so heavy rain interrupts both and both recover when the front passes. What actually decides how a household fares in weather is the quality of its own installation, not which service is behind it.

Get it sorted

Book a technician

Tell us the make, the size and what the screen or decoder is doing. We will give you a time slot and a quote before anyone starts work.

218 Thornton Road
Thornton, Cape Town
info@capetvrepairs.co.za